Dip Pots Included in Meal Deals Zero-rated for VAT Purposes

A company that operates fast-food restaurants has successfully appealed against a decision that dip pots supplied with takeaway meal deals were part of a single standard-rated supply. The Upper Tribunal (UT) ruled that, in most circumstances, every element in a transaction which would be treated as a supply if provided on its own must be regarded as distinct and independent.

Until early 2019 the company had accounted for VAT on the basis that dip pots, when included in a takeaway meal deal, formed part of a single standard-rated supply. However, it subsequently decided that a meal deal should be treated as a multiple supply and components such as coleslaw, milkshakes and dip pots were thus zero-rated because that was how they were treated when they were sold on their own. The company successfully reclaimed VAT it considered it had wrongly accounted for on meal deals between October 2015 and September 2018, including £75,502 relating to dip pots.

The company made a further claim for a refund in respect of later VAT periods, including £30,937 relating to dip pots. That part of the claim was refused after HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) concluded that, while some elements of a meal deal could be treated as separate supplies as they could be consumed on their own, dip pots were ancillary to the supply of the hot food that formed part of the meal deal and were simply a means of better enjoying that food. HMRC took the view that its earlier decision to repay VAT relating to dip pots had been incorrect, and issued an assessment to recover the amounts repaid. The company appealed to the First-tier Tribunal (FTT).

The FTT considered that there was no reason in principle why two or more elements of a single transaction could not constitute a single supply whilst, at the same time, other elements of the same transaction constituted a separate supply. The fact that HMRC accepted that some elements of a meal deal were a separate supply did not mean that the dip pots must also form a separate supply. Dismissing the appeal, the FTT concluded that dip pots were a means of better enjoying the hot food included in the meal deal and were part of a single supply.

Ruling on the company's further appeal, the UT concluded that every supply, including every element in a multi-element transaction which would be a supply if provided on its own, must be regarded as distinct and independent unless it falls within one of the few exceptional cases where a derogation from that fundamental principle is permitted. Apart from legislative overrides, those exceptions require all the elements in a single transaction to constitute a single economic supply. The FTT's conclusion that some elements of a transaction could constitute a single supply while others constituted a separate supply had been an error of law.

The contents of this article are intended for general information purposes only and shall not be deemed to be, or constitute legal advice. We cannot accept responsibility for any loss as a result of acts or omissions taken in respect of this article.